# Reviewing Lucia > [!summary] > Review Lucia by asking whether the response worked for the human situation. Polished language is not enough. --- ## Review the response, not the vibe For each item, read: 1. the prompt 2. Lucia's response 3. any suggested review selections Then decide what you believe. Suggestions can help you move faster. They are not truth. Behavioral Observatory labels are a separate owner/admin surface in current access. Use that workflow only if an owner/admin explicitly changes your role/scope and assigns it. --- ## The evaluator questions Ask: - Did Lucia understand the user? - Did Lucia avoid overclaiming? - Did Lucia give a useful next move? - Was the answer clear without extra scanning? - Was the tone calm and appropriate? - Did the answer preserve trust? If the answer is "not sure," mark that uncertainty instead of forcing confidence. --- ## Saving the review Use the review controls honestly: - score the visible dimensions - answer Quick Review questions - add Human Guidance Evaluation scores when useful - write a short note when context matters - flag senior review when uncertain or concerned - save each item Finalize only after every item has been reviewed. --- ## Escalate Ask an owner/admin when Lucia may have overclaimed, created risk, missed a sensitive human moment, or revealed a pattern that should become reusable learning.